I personally don't think she is Tony's biological daughter. There are subtle hints (I counted about a dozen the 2nd time I watched the series) but I think Chase wanted it to remain ambiguous throughout. I haven't read anything on this topic so maybe it's common knowledge or highly debated or neither. Am I alone in this?
In fact, I'd like to speculate that Hunter (Meadow's friend) is in fact his daughter. I base this only on small clues that seem to be put in for a reason, and are out of place if not within this context. Why, in the 1st episode, when Tony is with his ducks in the pool, does it cut to Hunter looking out the window (we see a close-up of Hunter before we see Meadow). For a split second we're led to believe this girl we're seeing is Tony's daughter, until the next shot in the kitchen that pans over to Meadow. Then, towards the end of the series when Hunter is visiting Meadow, she tells Carmela she dropped out of school (like Tony did). "That was always you", Carmela says.
Carmela looks at the painting of the white baby in the gallery, and Meadow's dark skin is purposely contrast against it. "When Meadow was born, oh my God she's so dark".
When MEADOW GOLD loses the race, Chris says "By a c*nt hair". He could have said anything else.
And of course, Meadow is not there with the family at the end. This can be for a number of reasons, the end scene is still a mystery in many regards. For one, if she had parked her car successfully the 1st time then she would be sitting next to Tony and caught in the crossfire. Parking incorrectly saved her life.
Re: Could Meadow not be Tony's daughter?
2Like I said in reference to whether or not Chris flipped on Tony before being killed:
We'll never know if the frenchman killed by Bobby was in fact Harpo. In this series, not everything is proven. But it could still be the case. That's the art of it.
We'll never know if the frenchman killed by Bobby was in fact Harpo. In this series, not everything is proven. But it could still be the case. That's the art of it.
Re: Could Meadow not be Tony's daughter?
3Hey maybe Livia wasn't Tony's mother or maybe Meadow was Tony and Janice's daughter and Harpo was Hunter's father...
Re: Could Meadow not be Tony's daughter?
4The main reason why this is possible to me is that Carmela was not the saint she thought she was. Maybe her anger towards Tony through the initial years was guilt?
Re: Could Meadow not be Tony's daughter?
6With a show as structured as this, you have to interpret everything in the frame as intentional. Do that and you pick up on dozens of hidden meanings they stuffed in both visually and between the lines.Billyv wrote:lol. take some more pills
If Artie had kept his hair, he would have become the boss eventually.
Re: Could Meadow not be Tony's daughter?
7WOW! Can't tell if you're actually being serious or not!!