Johnny Sack is deeply suspicious of Tony. He thinks Tony is secretly in cahoots with Little Carmine. He has never trusted Tony, and he resents Tony for not whacking Little Carmine after he'd given him the order. So he starts having Tony followed. Or he hears scuttlebutt that Tony's seeing a psychiatrist and has him followed. Either way, Johnny Sack finds out about Dr. Melfi. Up until now, only Christopher, Paulie, and Silvio know Tony's been seeing a psychiatrist and even they don't know her name. Now Sack finds out.
Johnny Sack is completely paranoid and will be immediately convinced that Tony has told Dr. Melfi too much, either intentionally or unintentionally. Either he confronts Tony and tells him to whack Dr. Melfi, or he has her killed himself. Either way it sets up a confrontation with Tony, because Johnny Sack won't know that Tony has feelings for Dr. Melfi.
Johnny Sack gives Tony a choice. Kill your shrink, or we'll kill your shrink. Either way she's got to go for the good of the families. Otherwise, Johnny Sack will tell the heads of the other families, the russians, and everybody else important, that Tony's been seeing a psychiatrist. Tony would never be trusted again. He'd be finished in "This Thing of Ours" He'd get whacked by somebody who is paranoid enough to think he might be telling Melfi secrets in his sessions. Melfi must go. Tony then has a choice, save his career in the mafia or save Dr. Melfi.
I think its obvious he can't keep his Melfi sessions as secret as they have been. It will get out. And when it does, Tony will have some hard decisions to make. Can he whack Dr. Melfi after all she's done for him?
</p>
Return to “Episode 5.09: Unidentified Black Males”
- Featured Discussions
- - The Many Saints of Newark
- - James Gandolfini Remembered
- - Sopranos Symbolism and Subtext
- - Sopranos in the News
- - Sopranos Individual Episode Forums
- - - Season 1
- - - - Episode 1.01: The Sopranos
- - - - Episode 1.02: 46 Long
- - - - Episode 1.03: Denial, Anger, Acceptance
- - - - Episode 1.04: Meadowlands
- - - - Episode 1.05: College
- - - - Episode 1.06: Pax Soprana
- - - - Episode 1.07: Down Neck
- - - - Episode 1.08: The Legend of Tennessee Moltisanti
- - - - Episode 1.09: Boca
- - - - Episode 1.10: A Hit Is a Hit
- - - - Episode 1.11: Nobody Knows Anything
- - - - Episode 1.12: Isabella
- - - - Episode 1.13: I Dream of Jeannie Cusamano
- - - Season 2
- - - - Episode 2.01: Guy Walks Into a Psychiatrist's Office
- - - - Episode 2.02: Do Not Resuscitate
- - - - Episode 2.03: Toodle-Fucking-Oo
- - - - Episode 2.04: Commendatori
- - - - Episode 2.05: Big Girls Don't Cry
- - - - Episode 2.06: The Happy Wanderer
- - - - Episode 2.07: D-Girl
- - - - Episode 2.08: Full Leather Jacket
- - - - Episode 2.09: From Where to Eternity
- - - - Episode 2.10: Bust Out
- - - - Episode 2.11: House Arrest
- - - - Episode 2.12: The Knight in White Satin Armor
- - - - Episode 2.13: Funhouse
- - - Season 3
- - - - Episode 3.01: Mr. Ruggerio's Neighborhood
- - - - Episode 3.02: Proshai, Livushka
- - - - Episode 3.03: Fortunate Son
- - - - Episode 3.04: Employee of the Month
- - - - Episode 3.05: Another Toothpick
- - - - Episode 3.06: University
- - - - Episode 3.07: Second Opinion
- - - - Episode 3.08: He Is Risen
- - - - Episode 3.09: The Telltale Moozadell
- - - - Episode 3.10: To Save Us All from Satan's Power
- - - - Episode 3.11: Pine Barrens
- - - - Episode 3.12: Amour Fou
- - - - Episode 3.13: Army of One
- - - Season 4
- - - - Episode 4.01: For All Debts Public and Private
- - - - Episode 4.02: No Show
- - - - Episode 4.03: Christopher
- - - - Episode 4.04: The Weight
- - - - Episode 4.05: Pie-O-My
- - - - Episode 4.06: Everbody Hurts
- - - - Episode 4.07: Watching Too Much Television
- - - - Episode 4.08: Mergers and Acquisitions
- - - - Episode 4.09: Whoever Did This
- - - - Episode 4.10: The Strong, Silent Type
- - - - Episode 4.11: Calling All Cars
- - - - Episode 4.12: Eloise
- - - - Episode 4.13: Whitecaps
- - - Season 5
- - - - Episode 5.01: Two Tonys
- - - - Episode 5.02: Rat Pack
- - - - Episode 5.03: Where's Johnny?
- - - - Episode 5.04: All Happy Families
- - - - Episode 5.05: Irregular Around the Margins
- - - - Episode 5.06: Sentimental Education
- - - - Episode 5.07: In Camelot
- - - - Episode 5.08: Marco Polo
- - - - Episode 5.09: Unidentified Black Males
- - - - Episode 5.10: Cold Cuts
- - - - Episode 5.11: The Test Dream
- - - - Episode 5.12: Long Term Parking
- - - - Episode 5.13: All Due Respect
- - - Season 6, Part 1
- - - - Episode 6.01: Members Only
- - - - Episode 6.02: Join the Club
- - - - Episode 6.03: Mayham
- - - - Episode 6.04: The Fleshy Part of the Thigh
- - - - Episode 6.05: Mr. and Mrs. John Sacrimoni Request
- - - - Episode 6.06: Live Free or Die
- - - - Episode 6.07: Luxury Lounge
- - - - Episode 6.08: Johnny Cakes
- - - - Episode 6.09: The Ride
- - - - Episode 6.10: Moe N' Joe
- - - - Episode 6.11: Cold Stones
- - - - Episode 6.12: Kaisha
- - - Season 6, Part 2
- - - - Episode 6.13: Soprano Home Movies
- - - - Episode 6.14: Stage 5
- - - - Episode 6.15: Remember When
- - - - Episode 6.16: Chasing It
- - - - Episode 6.17: Walk Like a Man
- - - - Episode 6.18: Kennedy and Heidi
- - - - Episode 6.19: The Second Coming
- - - - Episode 6.20: The Blue Comet
- - - - Episode 6.21: Made in America
- Other Sopranos Discussions
- - Sopranos Voting Booth
- - Music on The Sopranos
- - The Kitchen Sink
- - - Sopranos FAQ
- - The Movie Never Ends
- - Chase Lounge Archives
- - - Thank You, FlyOnMelfisWall
- - - "Proshai, Sopranos: A Final Toast from The Chase Lounge"
- - - Season 6, Parts 1 and 2, Spoilers/Spoiler-Based Speculation
- - - Season 6, Part 2, Non Spoiler-Based Speculation/Discussion
- - - Request a Sitdown (Pre-2016)
- Other Forums
- - David Chase B.S. ('Besides Sopranos' of Course!)
- - Literature and Film
- - Television
- - - Mad Men
- - - Boardwalk Empire
- - Satriale's Meet Market
- This Thing of Ours: Matters Relating to The Chase Lounge and Its Members
- - Posting Policies
- - Request a Sitdown